"It's okay. I feel like this could be an everyday type of scent. It’s acceptable, but it would not be my top choice."
—Melissa P., 29
Polo Blue Sport ($73 for 4.2 oz.) by Ralph Lauren, amazon.com
"I could picture myself smelling this on a guy when he's out and about in Central Park. It's an everyday kind of thing. It's powerful, but in a good way. It's not over-powering."
—Christina H., 37
Success ($62 for 3.4 oz.) by Trump, macys.com
"It's kind of piney. If you weren't careful, like you doused yourself, it'd be like the air fresheners that cab drivers use. But I think if it was done right it'd be nice."
—Beth G., 41
Z Zegna ($33 for 1.7 oz.) by Ermenegildo Zegna, amazon.com
"It smells expensive. It's rich, filled with flavor. I could see some guy, a country-club kind of guy wearing this — someone who’s all-American."
—Michelle L., 24
Big Pony ($50 for 2.5 oz.) by Ralph Lauren, ralphlauren.com
More from Esquire: